4 Mistakes to Avoid When Filing a Car Accident Claim

design
house

The aftermath of a car accident can be difficult to deal with, especially if you have been injured and/or you have never been in a car accident before. Although you may be focused on physically recovering and repairing the damage caused by a traffic collision, one of the other important things you will have to do will be to contact your insurance company and report the accident to get your claim started.

When filing a car accident claim with insurers, here are some common mistakes to avoid, an experienced Littleton car accident lawyer explains.
When filing a car accident claim with insurers, here are some common mistakes to avoid, an experienced Littleton car accident lawyer explains.

Given the fact that insurance companies are not typically on claimants’ sides after traffic accidents (because insurers are, instead, generally looking out for their own profits), what you do and say when filing a claim is important to:

  • Protecting your rights and interests
  • Avoiding giving insurers “reasons” to undervalue or deny your claim
  • Getting the payouts you likely deserve.

So, below, we’ll point out some of the most important mistakes to avoid making when it comes time to dealing with insurers after traffic wrecks.

When Submitting a Car Accident Claim, Do NOT…

1 – Wait too long to contact your insurance company

Auto policies usually have strict time limits for reporting accidents to insurance companies. In some cases, these limits can be as short as 48 to 72 hours after a collision.

So, don’t procrastinate contacting your insurer after a collision to report the accident.

2 – Give an official statement to an insurer if you are not prepared to do so.

When you first report a collision to an insurance company, your agent may be eager to get you to make an official statement (i.e., a recorded statement) regarding the collision. You should know, however, that:

  • You can refuse this request.
  • You should refuse to provide such a statement if you are not prepared.

This is because your statement can be used against you later to try to undercut or possibly even deny your claim. If you aren’t prepared, there are far greater chances you will say something you don’t mean to (like giving an accidental admission of fault) or possibly forget important details.

3 – Accept a settlement check before speaking to an attorney.

Insurers can be tricky, and one tactic they can use to try to get people to accept lower settlements is to simply send them checks. Upon these checks being cashed, the insurer considers the claim closed.

So, if you receive a check from an insurer after a car accident, do not sign it or deposit it before you speak to an attorney who can tell you if the offer is sufficient (or if you are being low-balled and should hold out for the full amount you deserve).

4 – Accept a claim denial for a valid car accident claim.

Not all claim denials are legitimate, and appealing wrongful denials can be crucial to getting the payouts you deserve. So, if your car accident claim has been denied by an insurer, it’s time to contact an attorney and find out what the next steps are for standing up to an insurance company and fighting for the compensation to which you are entitled.

Contact a Littleton Car Accident Lawyer at Littleton Lawyers™

Have you been hurt in a car accident caused by negligence? If so, it’s time to contact an experienced Littleton car accident lawyer at Littleton Lawyers™.

To get more information about your potential case and rights, meet with us for a free, no obligations initial consultation. To set up a meeting, call us at (303) 794-7422 or email us using the form on this page.

Middle-aged insurance agent sitting and working at his desk
June 3, 2026
What Is Insurance Bad Faith in Colorado and How Can It Affect Your Claim?
designdesign
When individuals purchase insurance coverage, they expect their insurance company to honor the promises outlined in the policy. Unfortunately, insurance […]
View more
right double arrowdesign
young man with moustache using phone
July 18, 2025
What Can You Do If Your Insurance Claim Is Denied in Colorado?
designdesign
Dealing with property damage, injury, or illness is stressful enough. When your insurance company adds to that stress by denying […]
View more
right double arrowdesign
Group Discussion
January 13, 2025
When Should You Consider Litigation for a Business Dispute?
designdesign
In the fast-paced world of business, disagreements and conflicts can arise between partners, vendors, customers, or other stakeholders. While many […]
View more
right double arrowdesign

Get in Touch

Need Legal Help?

design
The attorneys at Littleton Lawyers™ have experience battling insurance companies to get clients the money they deserve. If you have an insurance dispute you need help with call 303-562-1507 or email us via the contact form below.
littletonlawyers logo
The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. We welcome your calls, letters and email; however contacting us does NOT create an attorney-client relationship.
Posted on Google Google
Renee Johnson profile picture
Renee Johnson
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Amazing!! If your looking and for legal help look no further. Mike Bhar and his lovely assistant Lana are amazing. Prompt, compassionate and really know what they are doing. Our family went through hardships after being ran over while on a motorcycle. The team guided us through the process and truly served us justice when the courts failed to do so. Mike was reassuring and took away the anxiety I had throughout the whole process. We were able to get the help for my injuries that were really needed and help get us back on our feet. We will forever be grateful for the help recieved by Mike and Lana at Littleton Lawyers. The event was traumatic and left a dent in our lives that almost crashed everything we have built. Not sure where we would be without these fantastic people. Saved our family from the worst. If your looking for honesty integrity and people that are passionate about what they do and will do it with confidence call Mike. I'll never call anyone else again for my legal troubles. Wonderful people that are human just like the rest of us. They will fight for you and everything that matters most. ❤️ Thank you guys again! The amount of gratitude I feel for these people simply can't be put into just one small review. Hopefully others that may be facing unfortunate hardships and need the legal help see this and make the call. Just do it!
Posted on Google Google
Enzo The Alterist profile picture
Enzo The Alterist
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Mike Bahr is a real stand up guy! Helping me get through this case of bad faith practices against my insurance company! 10/10 recommend!
Posted on Google Google
Ignacio Cohen profile picture
Ignacio Cohen
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Michael and Ben possess extensive knowledge of the insurance sector and will not hesitate to inform you if they believe the case lacks merit. Their guidance provided to our shared client during the legal consultation was exceptional. I highly recommend their services.
Posted on Google Google
Vikki Ross profile picture
Vikki Ross
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Michael Bahr is absolutely amazing! I was in a head on collision and after talking with several attorneys decided to go with Mike Bahr. I couldn’t be happier with how everything turned out. He is compassionate, reasonable, and a good lawyer all together. I was able to claim the maximum benefits from both my insurance and the at-fault parties due to the extent of my injuries. When you are in an accident there is a lot of unknowns that add additional stress on top of trying to heal. Mike was able to answer all the questions I had and made sure I was focused on recovery. On top of just being an outstanding person and attorney he also was reasonably priced. Some attorneys are only in it for the money, but Mike Bahr genuinely seems like he wants to help people. He was extremely helpful during one of the most stressful times in my life and for that I couldn’t be more grateful. If you are ever involved in an accident I 100% would recommend reaching out to Mike Bahr.
Posted on Google Google
Lindsey Taylor-Bahr profile picture
Lindsey Taylor-Bahr
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Michael Bahr is downright the best lawyer in town! The most giving, detail oriented, and caring lawyer (if that exists). Would definitely recommend for any insurance related claims you are needing assistance with.
Posted on Google Google
Lisa Higdon profile picture
Lisa Higdon
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Michael Bahr was very prompt in talking with me about my issue and he helped me get my issue resolved quickly and professionally when we had problems with an insurance company.
Posted on Google Google
nicole fischer profile picture
nicole fischer
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
Mike and Ben both worked on my case against the seller of my house that did not disclose a mouse infestation. Both of them listened to my case and discussed possible strategies to help me win. They had very little time to prepare (roughly a month) between the mediation and the trial. They were both very sympathetic to what had been an incredibly stressful situation. Because of Ben and Mike's help I ended up winning my case and I am beyond grateful for their help.
Posted on Google Google
pat lobato profile picture
pat lobato
Google star 1Google star 2Google star 3Google star 4Google star 5Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google.
This office is so amazing, I want to share my experience about these amazing two people we met, Michael Bahr and Renee Vigil, We reached out to them to get help with fighting for grandparents rights, Due to my Son Passed away and now the ex-daughter in law wants to restrict us from seeing our grandkids. We had hired an other lawyer who was top of the line Lawyer only to tap out of retainer fee of thousands of dollars to get really nowhere, When I met Michael and Renee I immediately felt the difference of them being Caring, Compassionate and felt they were not just lawyers but real people who felt my story. These 2 people are really there for you! I would refer them and consider them even only after a couple of visits at first they make you feel so comfortable to talk to. They have certainly have made us a friend of there's for life and don't need to ever! look for attorney else where if I ever need legal advice.
google icon
Copyright © 2026 Littleton Lawyers | XML Sitemap | HTML Sitemap | All Rights Reserved
Powered By:
Epic Web Results logo